Why Is There No Maseches Chanukah | The Chanukah Omission


Rabbi Dr. Eliezer Brodt

0:00 Introduction
2:35 Various omissions related to Chanukah
8:40 Early sources who ask this question about the Chanukah omission

11:00 The Chanukah controversy of 1891
15:45 Answer #1 Based on the Rambam things that everyone knew were not included in the Mishna
17:52 Answer #2 Mesechtas Chanukah was lost
19:00 Answer #3 Megilas Tannis
20:02 1908 Edition of Megilast Tannis
22:30 Deep dive into the Megilat Tannis
27:00 Megilat tannis in Americia in 1850’s
29:00 Aderes and R Yakov Kahan correspondence
30:20 Answer #4 Chasam Sofer Answer
34:30 Rabanu Hakodesh role in writing Mishna
35:20 Answer #5 Hidden Halachos
Chisuru Mechsrah on the Mishna
39:55 The rare work Chanukas Habeis
42:34 Chasm Sofer and mention of Pach Shemen Nes in All HaNissim

For questions and comments – contact Rabbi Dr. Brodt at eliezerbrodt@gmail.com.

For sponsorship opportunities and other topic possibilities – contact Rabbi Moshe Schwed at schwedm@ou.org

For information about the All Torah apps and websites please visit alltorah.org

Source: YouTube (Embedded).
Videos not loading? Contact your filter to whitelist JewishTidbits videos.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *